Marcia Cuttler

Commercial Specialist / REALTOR©

Marcia Cuttler is a Commercial Real Estate Specialist with American Property Group of Sarasota, Inc., bringing decades of local market knowledge and firsthand business ownership experience to every transaction.

A Sarasota resident since 1974, Marcia has owned several successful businesses and personally purchased commercial investment properties, giving her a strong understanding of the challenges buyers, sellers, landlords, and tenants face throughout the process.

Known for her resourcefulness, tenacity, attention to detail, and client-focused approach, Marcia helps clients navigate commercial real estate with confidence. Her experience includes assisting with commercial sales, leasing, investment properties, and tenant/landlord representation throughout the Sarasota market.

Whether you are buying, selling, or leasing commercial property in Sarasota, Marcia provides the local insight, responsiveness, and dedication needed to move the transaction forward.

Contact Marcia Cuttler

Cell: 941-544-1020

marcia@americanpropertygroup.com

Why Work With Marcia Cuttler

  • Marcia takes the time to understand each client’s business needs, location preferences, budget, and long-term goals. With her background as a business owner and commercial property investor, she brings a practical perspective to helping clients evaluate spaces that fit both their operations and future growth.

  • Marcia assists clients with commercial sales and leasing, including retail spaces, office properties, investment properties, landlord representation, and tenant representation throughout the Sarasota market.

  • Marcia combines decades of Sarasota market knowledge with firsthand experience owning businesses and commercial investment properties. She understands the stress that can come with buying, selling, or leasing commercial real estate and is known for being responsive, detailed, and committed to helping clients through each step.

  • Marcia focuses on commercial real estate in Sarasota and the surrounding Southwest Florida market, with deep local knowledge built from living and working in Sarasota since 1974.

Marcia’s Closed Sales & Leases

  • 2205 Industrial Blvd, Sarasota, FL

    41,685 SF Industrial Warehouse on 2.77 acres sold

  • 5900 S Tamiami Trl, Sarasota, FL

    Retail condo sold

  • 2195-2199 Princeton St, Sarasota, FL

    Multi tenant industrial property sold & leased

What People Are Saying

“Had a great experience working with Marcia Cuttler at American Property Group. Would definitely do business with her again. Very knowledgeable about the area, and attentive to details.”

— J.G.

“I have personally know Marcia Cuttler for over 40 years and would not consider doing any commercial real estate transactions with our her. Her commitment to her client's are unparalleled.”

— Richard W.

“I met Marcia Cuttler through American Property Group and was right off impressed with her Knowledge of the Sarasota commercial property market. She has been a local resident for many years and knows the history of many properties. She is always just a text away and looks out for her client. Thanks again Ms Cuttler.”

— Doug A.

Marcia’s Featured Listings